BOTTLES TASTED RATING

Distillery - Bottlers - Age - Distilled - Bottled - ABV - Type of bottle

 Note Rate When Tasted
1 Port Ellen O.B. 24 y.o. 1978 2003 57.3% 70cl 3rd Realise 4.73 2005
2 Longrow O.B. 10 y.o. 1991    46% 70cl    4.39 2005
3 Ardbeg Silver Seal 12 y.o. 1992 2004 46% 70cl Collecting whisky 4.29 2005
Caol Ila O.B. 12 y.o. 1995 2007 43% 70cl Moscatel Finish 2010
5 Glemorangie O.B.       46% 70cl Signet 4.22 2011
6 Highland Park O.B. 18 y.o.       43% 70cl    4.18 2006
  Balvenie O.B. 30 y.o.     47.3%  70cl     2010
8 Port Ellen Waddel Hepburn 26 y.o. 1983 2009 56% 70cl Milano Whisky Festival 2009 4.15 2010
9 Mortlach Waddel Hepburn 16 y.o 9/1992 8/2009 58.7% 70cl Milano Whisky Festival 2009 4.13 2010
10 Caol Ila O.B. 25 y.o. 1979 2005 58.4% 70cl    4.11 2006
11 Glenlivet O.B. 16 y.o. 2008 56.2% 70cl Nadurra Batch 0308E 4.07 2009
12 Bruichladdich James MacArthur's 20 y.o. 1988 2008 52.6% 70cl Cask N° 1883 4.05 2011
13 Rosebank O.B. 25 y.o. 1981 2007 61.4% 70cl 4.03 2010
14 Port Ellen Waddel Hepburn 23 y.o. 1983 2006 54.1% 70cl Collecting whisky 4.01 2006
15 Caol Ila Douglas Laing 12 y.o. 9/1991 03/2003 50% 70cl Old Malt Cask 3.99 2005
16 Laphroaig* O.B. 10 y.o.       55.7% 1L Cask strength 3.98 2005/08
17 Caol Ila Signatory 23 y.o. 16.05.84 01.02.08 55.6% 70cl Single cask N° 3633 3.97 2010
18 Port Ellen Douglas MacGibbon 18 y.o. Winter 81 Spring 2000 43% 70cl 3.96 2007
19 Dallas Dhu O.B. 22 y.o.       46% 70cl Union of the Crown 3.95 2005
Macallan O.B. 10 y.o.       58.8% 1L Cask Strength 2005
Caol Ila O.B. 23 y.o. 1978 5/2002 61.7% 70cl Rare Malts 2006
Caol Ila James MacArthur's 26 y.o. 55.2% 70cl 2010

23

 Macallan O.B. 18 y.o. 1985 2003 43% 70cl    3.92 2005
Ardbeg Speymalt LTD    1990 2001 57.1% 70cl Spirit of Scotland 2005

25

 Strathisla Gordon & MacPhail    1967 2003 54.3% 70cl 35th Barmetro 3.88 2005
Talisker** O.B. 18 y.o. 45.8% 70cl 2005/07/09

27

 Laphroaig O.B. 55% 70cl Cairdeas 3.85 2009
28 Tomatin Speciality Drinks LTD 30 y.o. 4/1972 7/2002 44.2% 70cl LTD 444 bottles 3.84 2005
Macallan James MacArthur's 15 y.o. 1989 2004 62.2% 70cl Cask N° 1249 2005
Bowmore James MacArthur's 17 y.o. 1989 2006 51% 70cl The way of spirits 2007
Talisker O.B. 57% 1L 57° North 2008
Bruichladdich 5 y.o. 2002 2008 46% 70cl Port Charlotte - 42th Barmetro 2008
33 Caol Ila Waddel Hepburn 12 y.o. 1993 2005 46% 70cl Collecting whisky 3.82 2006
Glen Grant Gordon & MacPhail 21 y.o       40% 70cl White cup - Screw cup 2006
  Glenrothes O.B.   1985 2005 43% 70cl     2011
36 Springbank O.B. 10 y.o.       57% 70cl 100° Proof - Yellow label 3.80 2005
Talisker O.B. 1991 2004 45.8% 70cl Double Matured 2007
Glenlivet O.B. 16 y.o. 1991 2008 59.8% 50cl Batch GL16008 2008
Highland Park* O.B. 18 y.o. 43% 70cl Flat Bottle 2007/09
40 Ardbeg O.B. 1990 2004 55% 70cl CASK STRENGTH 3.79 2006
Bruichladdich O.B. 15 y.o.       46% 70cl First Edition NO Islay bottling 2004
42 Caol Ila Waddel Hepburn 16 y.o. 1990 2006 56.3% 70cl Milano Whisky Festival 2006 3.76 2007
Glenrothes James MacArthur's 17 y.o. 1988 2006 54.1% 70cl 2006
44 Islay James MacArthur's 16 y.o. 55% 70cl Vatted Malt 3.75 2010
Longmorn* James MacArthur's 15 y.o. 5/1992 9/2007 59.5% 70cl Milano Whisky Festival 2007 2009/10
46 Lagavulin O.B. 12 y.o. 1995 2008 48% 70cl Friends of Classic Malt 3.73 2009
47 Macallan O.B. 10 y.o. 58.6% 1L Cask Strength 3.72 2007
48 Lagavulin** O.B. 12 y.o.    2004 58.2% 70cl 3.71 2005/09/10
Glenfiddich O.B. 15 y.o. 51% 1L Cask Strength 2007
Clynelish James MacArthur's 10 y.o. 1995 2006 58.9% 70cl The way of spirits 2007
Caol Ila O.B. 1996 2009 43% 70cl Moscatel Finish 2010
52 Caol Ila Silver Seal 8 y.o. 1995 2003 55.9% 70cl Collecting whisky 3.69 2004
53 Glenrothes Caledonian 1989 53.5% 70cl 3.67 2005
Glenlivet O.B. 13 y.o 2008 59.1% 70cl Faemussach 2010
55 Ardbeg* O.B. 1990 2006 46% 70cl Airigh Nam Beist 3.66 2006/10
56 Bowmore John Milroy    1990 1999 50% 70cl Millennium selection 3.65 2004
57 Ardbeg Douglas Laing 15 y.o. 1991 2006 50.9% 70cl 40th Anniversary Barmetro (OMC) 3.64 2007
Caol Ila** O.B. 18 y.o.       43% 70cl    2006/07
59 Glenlivet O.B. 16 y.o. 2009 53.6% 70cl Nadurra Batch 0109G 3.63 2010
60 Linkwood* James MacArthur's 11 y.o. 1989 2001 57.2% 70cl Collecting whisky 3.62 2005/06
61 Glenlivet O.B. 16 y.o. 1988 2004 56.9% 50cl Cask strength edition GL16003 3.61 2005
Mortlach Gordon & MacPhail 21 y.o.       40% 70cl Sestante import 2005
  Balvenie O.B. 21 y.o.     40% 70cl Portwood   2010
64 Ardbeg Gordon & MacPhail    1996 2005 46% 70cl Cask N° 906 3.60 2006
65 Macallan O.B. 25 y.o.       43% 70cl    3.59 2005
Lagavulin O.B.    1986 2002 43% 70cl Double Matured 2004
Talisker O.B.          45.8% 70cl 175° Anniversary 2006
Ardbeg O.B. 1998 2007 54.1% 70cl Almost there 2007
69 Bruichladdich O.B. 10 y.o. 43% 75cl Double gold award 3.58 2008
  Caol Ila James MacArthur's 14 y.o. 1996 2010 58.4% 70cl Sherry Wood 2010
71 Macallan O.B. 18 y.o. 1986 2004 43% 70cl    3.57 2006
Lagavulin O.B. 12 y.o. 2009 57.9% 70cl 2010
73 Ardbeg O.B. 1998 2008 55.9% 70cl Reinassance 3.56 2008
Ardbeg* O.B. 59.8% 70cl Supernova 2009/11
Clynelish Cadenhead's 15 y.o. 1992 2007 56.1% 70cl 2009
76 Hazelburn O.B. 8 y.o. 46% 70cl 3.54 2007
Allt-A-Bhainne James MacArthur's 14 y.o. 1993 2007 53.7% 70cl Collecting whisky 2008
78 Bowmore O.B.       51.5% 70cl Dawn-Port Casked 3.52 2009
Ardbeg* O.B. 57.1% 70cl Corryvreckan 2010/11
Longmorn James MacAthur's 12 y.o. 60.1% 70cl 2010
  Bowmore James MacArthur's 13 y.o. 1996 2009 58.8% 70cl Cask N°960003   2011
82 Bunnahabhain O.B. 12 y.o.       40% 75cl 80's edition 3.49 2004
Balvenie O.B. 12 y.o. 43% 70cl Doublewood 2010
  Balvenie* O.B. 17 y.o. 2009 43% 70cl Madeira Cask   2010
  Glenrothes O.B.   1991 2009 43% 70cl     2011
86 Glenmorangie* O.B. 18 y.o. 43% 70cl New bottle 3.48 2009/11
87 Glenfarclas O.B. 10 y.o.       40% 75cl 80's edition 3.47 2005
Ardbeg O.B. 54.2% 70cl Uigeadail (3rd edition) 2006
89 Springbank O.B. 9 y.o. 10.05.96 10.12.05 56.7% 70cl Scotch Unlimited 3.46 2007
  Glen Elgin James MacArthur's 17 y.o. 1991 5/2008 52% 70cl Milano Whisky Festival 2008   2010
91 Macallan Silver Seal 13 y.o. 1990 2003 46% 70cl Collecting whisky 3.45 2005
Brora Gordon & MacPhail 20 y.o. 1982 2002 40% 70cl Collecting whisky 2005
Glenlivet** O.B. 18 y.o. 43% 70cl 2006/09
Dalmore O.B.          43% 750ml Cigar Malt 2005
95 Glen Scotia O.B. 14 y.o.       40% 70cl    3.44 2006
Highland Park* James MacArthur's 13 y.o. 1992 2005 50% 70cl Collecting whisky 2006
Bowmore Waddel H. 8 y.o. 1997 2006 58.8% 70cl Collecting whisky 2006
  Balvenie O.B. 15 y.o. 22.04.94 30.04.09 48.7% 70cl Cask N° 713   2010
99 Dufftown Silver Seal 20 y.o. 10/1981 2001 50% 70cl    3.43 2005
100 Balvenie O.B. 12 y.o. 43% 1L Double Wood 3.37 2006
Cragganmore* James MacArthur's 12 y.o. 1997 9/2009 50% 70cl Milano Whisky Festival 2009 2010
Ardbeg* O.B. 57.3% 70cl Rollercoaster 2010/11
Caol Ila Duncan Taylor 14 y.o. 1991 2005 46% 70cl The way of spirits 2008
104 Glen Spey James MacArthur's 12 y.o.       43% 70cl    3.36 2006
Laphroaig Waddell Hepburn 11 y.o. 57.5% 70cl Slow Food (MB Selection) 2010
106 Glen Scotia Silver Seal 12 y.o. 1991  9/2003  43% 70cl    3.35 2005
Longrow O.B. 10 y.o. 1994 46% 70cl 2007
Springbank O.B. 10 y.o. 1997 55.2% 70cl Vintage 1997 2007
109 Laphroaig O.B. 18 y.o.     48% 70cl   3.34 2010
110 Ardbeg O.B. 1990 2007 46% 70cl Airigh Nam Beist 3.32 2008
Macallan O.B. 10 y.o. 58.7% 1L Cask Strenght 2008
Laphroaig O.B. 48% 1L Triple Wood 2009
113 Bruichladdich O.B. 15 y.o. 43% 70cl White label 3.30 2009
Glenlivet* O.B. 15 y.o.       43% 1L    2005/09
115 Glenlivet James MacArthur's 9 y.o. 1996 2006 58.5% 70cl The way of spirits 3.29 2006
  Bowmore James MacArthur's 10 y.o. 2000 2010 45% 70cl     2011
Bowmore O.B. 50% 70cl Dusk-Bordeaux wine casked 2009
118 Bowmore O.B. 15 y.o. 43% 1L Mariner-Paper label 3.28 2009
Bowmore* O.B. 18 y.o. 43% 70cl 2007/09
120 Ardbeg** O.B. 54.2% 70cl UIGEADAIL (2009 Edition) 3.27 2010/11
121 Balvenie O.B. 15 y.o. 12.04.91 7.11.06 47.8% 70cl Single Barrel Cask N° 530 3.26 2007
Ardbeg O.B. 1990 2008 46% 70cl Airigh Nam Beist 2010
123 Springbank O.B. 10 y.o. 46% 70cl Black label 3.25 2007
Laphroaig O.B. 15 y.o. 43% 70cl 2009
125 Tamdhu James MacArthur's 1989 2004 58.2% 70cl Cask N° 8132 3.24 2009
  Lagavulin O.B. 12 y.o. 2006 57.5% 70cl 2010
127 Glenfiddich O.B. 15 y.o.       43% 1L Solera reserve 3.23 2005
Longmorn O.B. 17 y.o. 1991 2008 49.4% 50cl Batch LM17005 2008
129 Highland Park* O.B. 16 y.o. 40% 1L    3.22 2006/07
Caol Ila Waddell Hepburn 12 y.o. 1996 2008 46% 70cl The way of spirits 2009
131 Bruichladdich O.B. 14 y.o. 1991 2005 46% 70cl Yellow Submarine 3.21 2006
Laphroaig** O.B. 48% 70cl Quarter Cask 2005/06/09
133 Ardbeg** O.B.    1998 2006 56.2% 70cl Still Young 3.20 2006/09/10
134 Clynelish O.B. 1992 2008 46% 70cl Double Matured 3.19 2009
135 Caol Ila O.B.          59.3% 70cl Cask Strength (2006 edition) 3.18 2006
Macallan O.B. 15 y.o. 40% 70cl Fine oak 2009
Glenlivet James MacArthur's 11 y.o. 9/1996 9/2007 43% 70cl Milano Whisky Festival 2007 2010
138 Ardbeg O.B. 10 y.o. 46% 70cl TEN 3.16 2006
Bowmore W.Cadenhead's 16 y.o. 1992 2008 52.1% 70cl 2010
Milton Duff James MacArthur's 12 y.o. 43% 70cl 2010
  Glenmorangie O.B. 10 y.o.     40% 70cl The Original   2011
142 Linkwood James MacArthur's 18 y.o. 50.1% 70cl 3.15 2010
143 Caol Ila Gordon & MacPhail    1995 2004 40% 70cl    3.14 2006
Milton-Duff James MacArthur's 10 y.o. 43% 70cl 2007
145 Bunnahabhain O.B. 12 y.o. 43% 1L 3.12 2008
Bruichladdich* James MacArthur 13 y.o. 1991 2004 58.7% 70cl 2010
  Balvenie O.B. 12 y.o.     40% 70cl Doublewood   2010
148 Ardbeg* O.B. 10 y.o. 46% 70cl TEN (2010 Edition) 3.11 2010/11
149 Tobermory O.B. 10 y.o.       40% 70cl    3.09 2006
150 Glenlivet** O.B. 15 y.o. 40% 70cl French Oak Reserve 3.08 2009/10
151 Highland Park O.B.          40% 70cl Capella 3.07 2005
Ardbeg O.B. 17 y.o. 40% 70cl 17 2006
(Lagavulin) 1997 2006 46% 70cl ISLAY SINGLE MALT 2007
Jura James MacArthur's 15 y.o. 1992 2007 53.9% 70cl Valter Donadelli 2008
  Glentauchers James MacArthur's 14 y.o. 1990 1995 58.5% 70cl Cask N°14426   2011
156 Macallan O.B. 15 y.o.       43% 70cl Fine oak 3.06 2005
Ardbeg O.B.    1998 2004 58.3% 70cl Very Young 2006
(Laphroaig) Ian Macleod 8 y.o. 58.4% 70cl As we get it 2007
159 Bruichladdich O.B. 10 y.o.       43% 70cl Longitude 3.04 2005
Glenfiddich O.B. 18 y.o.       43% 70cl    2006
Macallan Gordon & MacPhail    1993 2001 40% 70cl Speymalt 2006
162 Laphroaig High Spirits 46% 70cl Islay 5 3.02 2009
163 Bowmore O.B. 43% 70cl Darkest-Sherry Casked 3.01 2009
  Glenrothes O.B.   1994 2010 43% 70cl     2011
  Bladnoch James MacArthur's 13 y.o. 1992 2005 56.9% 70cl Cask N° 752   2011
166 Clynelish Douglas Laing 12 y.o. 1989 2001 50% 70cl Sherry wood finish 3.00 2006
Glenrothes Gordon & MacPhail 1978 1995 40% 70cl Centenary Reserve 2008
168 Clynelish Wilson & Morgan   1989 2003 46% 70cl Marsala wood finish 2.99 2005
Rosebank Douglas Laing 12 y.o. 1989 2001 50% 70cl Oid Malt Cask 2007
170 Longmorn O.B. 16 y.o. 48% 70cl 2.98 2010
171 Strathisla O.B. 12 y.o. 43% 70cl 2.97 2010
  Glenmorangie* O.B. 12 y.o. 46% 70cl Necatar D'Or   2010/11
  Glenmorangie O.B. 12 y.o.     46% 70cl La Santa   2011
174 Highland Park O.B. 12 y.o. 40% 70cl Flat bottle 2.96 2007
175 Bruichladdich O.B.          50% 70cl 3D - II edition 2.95 2005
176 Glenmorangie O.B. 18 y.o. 43% 70cl 2.93 2007
177 Macallan O.B. 40% 50cl Forties 2.90 2008
178 Jura O.B.          45% 70cl Superstition 2.89 2005
Caol Ila O.B. 12 y.o.       43% 70cl    2006
180 Glenallachie O.B. 16 y.o. 1990 2006 57.8% 50cl Cask Strength Edition 2.88 2007
181 Glen Grant O.B. 10 y.o.       43% 75cl 70's edition 2.86 2005
Bowmore O.B. 12 y.o. 40% 1L Enigma 2008
183 Macallan O.B. 40% 50cl Fifties 2.85 2008
184 Glenmorangie* O.B. 12 y.o. 46% 70cl Quinta Ruban 2009/11
185 Highland Park O.B. 15 y.o. 43% 70cl Flat Bottle 2.83 2007
Aberlour James MacArthur's 14 y.o. 56.8% 70cl 2010
187 Macallan O.B. 10 y.o.       40% 70cl Fine oak 2.82 2005
Rosebank* Gordon & MacPhail     1990 2004 40% 70cl    2005/06
Bruichladdich James MacArthur's 14 y.o. 1991 2005 43% 70cl 2007
Dalmore O.B. 12 y.o 20.02.1992 43% 1L Black Pearl-Madeira Wood Finish 2008
191 Jura O.B. 16 y.o.       40% 70cl    2.80 2006
192 Bunnahabhain O.B. 46.3% 1L Darach Ur-Batch N°1 2.79 2009
  Bowmore James MacArthur's 10 y.o.     43% 70cl 2010
194 Macallan O.B. 42.8% 1L Whisky Maker's Selection 2.78 2007
195 Glenrothes O.B.       43% 70cl Select Reserve 2.77 2011
196 Serendipity Macdonald & Muir 12 y.o.       40% 70cl Vatted malt 2.76 2005
Glengoyne O.B. 40% 1L Burnfoot 2008
  Tomatin James MacArthur's 12 y.o.     43% 70cl     2011
  Jura O.B. 16 y.o.       40% 70cl      2010
200 Bowmore O.B.          40% 1L Surf - Brown label 2.75 2005
201 Glenlivet O.B. 12 y.o. 40% 70cl 2.73 2009
202 Glenmorangie O.B.          43% 70cl Madeira wood finish - Green label 2.72 2005
203 Macallan Gordon & MacPhail    1995    40% 70cl Speymalt 2.68 2005
204 Macallan O.B. 12 y.o. 1991 2003 40% 1L Elegancia 2.67 2005
205 Balblair O.B. 1986 2007 46% 1L 2.64 2008
206 Macallan O.B. 18 y.o. 43% 70cl Fine Oak 2.63 2009
207 Glenrothes O.B.   1998 2010 43% 70cl   2.59 2011
208 Arran O.B. 57% 70cl 100° Proof 2.58 2010
209 Caol Ila O.B. 8 y.o. 2007 64.9% 70cl Unpeated 2.56 2009
210 Lammerlaw O.B. 10 y.o.       43% 70cl New Zealand Malt 2.54 2006
211 Scapa O.B. 14 y.o.       40% 70cl    2.50 2005
Aberlour O.B. 60.2% 70cl A' Bunadh - Batch N°17   2007
Glen Grant James MacArthur's 11 y.o. 43% 70cl 2010
214 Ardbeg O.B. 40% 70cl Blasda 2.44 2009
215 Highland Park O.B. 1995 2006 59.6% 70cl 3rd Malt Tour 2.39 2007
216 Glenmorangie O.B.          43% 70cl Burgundy finish 2.36 2006
Arran O.B. 10 y.o. 46% 70cl 2009
In red are Collecting Whisky bottlings
* Indicate a double tasting ** Indicate a triple tasting
Note rating is from 1 to 5